Buckeye Superstore
Shelby, OH
Contact
Google Reviews
# Summary Staff members are consistently praised for their professionalism, personability, and willingness to go above and beyond, with multiple reviewers highlighting specific salespeople and finance managers who took time to address concerns and customize solutions. Customers report feeling comfortable and unpressured throughout the buying experience, with the dealership standing out for transparent communication, fair pricing, and even covering unexpected repair costs before delivery.
Found a gem at this dealership four and half hours away, and everyone there was helpful and kind. Keynen was fantastic to work with through texts, videos and even a FaceTime call that allowed me to look over the vehicle the best I could from almost 300 miles away. Wife and I decided to take a chance and drove to the dealership to see and test drive in person. Keynen did not misrepresent the vehicle and it was worth the trip; the dealer even took care of an unexpected mechanical issue at their expense before we drove it home. Cannot say enough good things about Keynen, Fred and the entire dealership. The worst part is they are so far away from us because we would definitely do business with them again! Highly recommend!
Recently had a horrible experience with another dealer and took a trip with the wife to Buckeye Superstore. Both of us walked out with newer vehicles and the team at Buckeye Superstore were all easy to deal with. Never felt pressured and Fred the finance manager was the best I’ve ever dealt with, literally explains everything and stayed late to answer all of our questions. 10/10 would recommend
Derek Zehner did an amazing job and the rest of the sales staff this is my second time buying a a vehicle here and both times have been amazing my parents have bought their last five vehicles here as well great customer service and great staff!!
Our salesman, Evan Strong, was the absolute best. He was professional but also personable.We found the perfect van for our family and we love it! We will be back for future vehicle purchases.
Even was my sales rep. He was absolutely amazing, someone who you could actually see yourself being friends with. He was very personable and extremely easy to connect with. They did not have exactly what I was wanting in a 2025 Jeep Wrangler so Evan walked us through, step by step to custom order exactly what we wanted. I wanted a Sahara but the Sahara did not come in the Mojito color that I wanted. So Evan explained that we could go with a Sport S and add any and/or all the Sahara options that I wanted (aside from the matching body color top). After placing our order, it only took like 27 days for us to get it. I was shocked that it only took that long to build my custom Wrangler from scratch. I absolutely LOVE my Wrangler and I may never do business with anyone, other than Buckeye, ever again. I have bought many vehicles in my time and this was by far my best experience that I've ever had. Even the closing of the deal took less than 20 minutes... probably would have taken less but I talk a lot. Lol
Get anonymous quotes from Buckeye Superstore
Submit your car request anonymously — Buckeye Superstore and other dealers in Shelby, OH will compete for your business. You choose who to reveal your contact info to.
Get quotes anonymously →Is this your dealership?
Claim this listing and your first bid is free — no credit card required to get started.
Claim this listing — first bid freeNo credit card required to sign up
How AutoAnon works for dealers
- Buyers submit anonymous vehicle requests
- Matched dealers compete with their best offer
- Buyer chooses — you get their contact info exclusively
- First bid is on us