Franchise Dealer

John Amato Hyundai

Menomonee Falls, WI

4.3(1,488 Google reviews)

Brands

Hyundai

Contact

N80W12650 Leon Rd, Menomonee Falls, WI 53051
(414) 357-8500johnamatohyundai.com/

Google Reviews

# Summary The dealership receives consistently high marks for exceptional customer service, particularly from individual staff members like Sam and Michael who are praised for their professionalism, attentiveness, and trustworthiness across both sales and service departments. However, one customer reported a significant service issue where a lug nut fell off after a tire rotation, raising concerns about quality control in maintenance procedures.

Ellen Lavinea month ago

My sales person Sam was great from the time I walked into John Amato Hyundai. He made me feel comfortable and let me know I could call him with any questions or if I needed anything. He has stood behind that statement. I brought my car in for a recall. The service department handled it, my car was taken care of within an hour while I sat comfortably in the waiting room. I was given an explanation of what was fixed and my car was returned to me after they washed it. My experience was great and I highly recommend John Amato Hyundai.

Kevin P2 weeks ago

The locking lug fell off the rear passenger side wheel after my tire rotation last Thursday. What should the torque be on those, as I am going to check all of the lug nuts. Thanks Kevin Piquette

Amy Badillo2 months ago

The reason why we chose to come to John Amato Hyundai for all of our service needs is because of Michael LeClaire. He's been the greatest Advisor we've ever worked with. He listens to our concerns, needs and always accommodates us with true professionalism. We actually followed him from West Allis where we live to Menomonee Falls because he is just that awesome and trustworthy. Thank you Michael LeClaire for all you do. The Badillo Family

Kris Straszewski7 months ago

I was dreading shopping for a new car, but I was so pleasantly surprised when I contacted John Amato Hyundai. Sam Othman answered my call and listened to my needs and experiences. He got right on searching for my new vehicle, a 2026 Hyundai Tucson Limited. He contacted me back right away and suggested that we make an appt. to see it. I was so impressed by his knowledge and his lack of pushiness. He put me right at ease. I was originally going to go with the Costco Auto Buying Program, but it had me going so far away to the dealership. The way that Sam handled the entire transaction made it easy to move forward and take the plunge. I am so glad that I did. The whole dealership was clean, warm and welcoming. Thanks so much John Amato, Sam and Rob for giving me a great car buying experience!

Richard Reitera month ago

A friend was supposed to have the same update as me to our new 2026 Tucson SEL but a bad accident on the highway was preventing him from making his time slot and called me to let me know because 9 out of 10 times I would have traveled the same route. Thinking outside the box, I called John Amato’s service center and explained to John the service manager the situation and asked if we could switch time slots so my friend could still get the update. I had a 1 hour later time slot than my friend. Without hesitation, John, the service-manager said yes, that is Customer Service.

Get anonymous quotes from John Amato Hyundai

Submit your car request anonymously — John Amato Hyundai and other dealers in Menomonee Falls, WI will compete for your business. You choose who to reveal your contact info to.

Get quotes anonymously →

Is this your dealership?

Claim this listing and your first bid is free — no credit card required to get started.

Claim this listing — first bid free

No credit card required to sign up

How AutoAnon works for dealers

  • Buyers submit anonymous vehicle requests
  • Matched dealers compete with their best offer
  • Buyer chooses — you get their contact info exclusively
  • First bid is on us
Learn more →